Home / Journal / Shortage and overrun
Crochet order shortage and overrun: writing the tolerance clause
A tolerance clause fixes, before production starts, how many pieces may differ from the ordered quantity, who carries that difference, and at what price it settles — so that the answer at shipment is arithmetic rather than an argument.
Hand-crochet orders almost never land on the exact number. Pieces are pulled at final inspection for a loose safety eye, an open seam or a size drift; yarn is allocated in cones that yield an uneven count; a set is short one component while the carton count is perfect. None of that is negligence, and none of it is fixed by asking the factory to try harder. It is fixed by deciding in advance what happens when the count moves.
The reason this goes wrong so often is that three different rulebooks get used interchangeably. A buyer quotes "the five per cent rule" from a letter of credit, a supplier quotes "three per cent is standard", and a lawyer points at the sale of goods convention — and all three are talking about different things, one of which does not even apply to toys counted per piece. The clause only works once those layers are separated.
1. Why piece counts drift · 2. Three layers that get confused · 3. Five things the clause must state · 4. Three clauses you can paste · 5. Sets are where shortages hide · 6. Over-shipment under a credit · 7. How the number gets established · 8. Our own internal band · 9. Questions
1. Why piece counts drift in a hand-crochet order
Four mechanisms account for nearly all of it, and each suggests a different remedy.
| Mechanism | What actually happens | Where it should be handled |
|---|---|---|
| Final-inspection rejections | Pieces removed after the order quantity was already booked — a pull-force failure, an uneven fill, a seam that fails the squeeze test | Tolerance band, plus a rework route before the count is struck |
| Yarn allocation rounding | A dye lot yields a whole number of pieces; the last partial cone is not spinnable into a full batch | Band stated per colour, not per order |
| Set composition | Cartons are complete, but a set inside is one component short | Unit of measure defined at component level |
| Subcontracted operations | Hand-finishing returned in partial batches, with some pieces held back for rework | Counting point fixed at the factory gate, not at the subcontractor |
The first two produce honest, small, one-directional movement — usually a shortfall. The last two produce the expensive kind: a count that looks correct on the packing list and is wrong in the box. A tolerance clause written only as a percentage addresses the first two and misses the last two entirely.
2. Three layers that get confused
Every "what is the normal tolerance" conversation mixes these up. Keep them apart and the numbers stop contradicting each other.
2.1 The contract layer — whatever you agreed
There is no statutory percentage for over- or under-delivery in cross-border craft trade. A three per cent band is common in garment and craft sourcing as a commercial starting point, and it is a reasonable one, but it exists only because someone wrote it down. If the purchase order is silent, the band is zero — and a zero band is the worst outcome for both sides, because every deviation then becomes a breach to be argued rather than a number to be applied.
2.2 The credit layer — UCP 600, which usually does not apply
When payment runs on a documentary credit, the Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (ICC Publication No. 600, 2007 Revision) supplies a default. Article 30(b) reads:
Read the proviso carefully. The five per cent exists only where the quantity is not stated as a number of packing units or individual items. Crochet plush is ordered, invoiced and packed by the piece and by the carton — exactly the case the proviso excludes. So for a per-piece toy order under a credit, Article 30(b) gives you nothing. Article 30(a) does allow ten per cent, but only if the credit itself uses the word "about" or "approximately" next to the quantity — and no buyer drafting a toy order wants that word in it.
The practical consequence is sharp: over-ship by three per cent on a credit that states 5,000 pieces, and the invoice exceeds the credit amount. That is a discrepancy, the bank may refuse the documents, and the excess sits at the destination unpaid. This is the single most common way a handshake-level tolerance turns into a payment problem.
2.3 The law layer — a right to choose, not a percentage
The UN Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods, Article 52(2), gives the buyer a choice rather than a number: where the seller delivers more than the contract quantity, the buyer may take delivery or refuse the excess, and must pay the contract rate for whatever excess it accepts. Article 51(1) does the mirror for short delivery — the remedies for non-conformity apply to the missing part, and the whole contract can only be avoided where the shortfall amounts to a fundamental breach.
Chinese law runs in parallel. Article 629 of the Civil Code provides that where the seller delivers more than the agreed quantity, the buyer may accept or refuse the excess. Article 621 is the one that catches buyers out: where an inspection period is agreed, the buyer must notify the seller of any quantity or quality non-conformity within it, and failure to notify is deemed acceptance that the quantity conforms. Where no period is agreed, notification must come within a reasonable time and in any event within two years of receipt.
Read together, the law says: you get a choice, but you lose it if you stay silent. That is why the notice window in the clause matters as much as the percentage.
3. Five things the clause must state
3.1 The unit of measure — down to the component
State the unit twice: the selling unit and the counting unit. "5,000 sets, each set comprising one doll and one blanket; counted per component at packing." Without the second half, a carton containing 100 dolls and 98 blankets passes every count on the packing list.
3.2 An asymmetric band
Symmetry is a drafting habit, not a commercial reality. Short and over cost the buyer different things: a shortfall of forty pieces can leave a purchase order to a retailer undeliverable, while an overrun of forty pieces is usually sellable but brings extra freight, duty and cash. Many buyers therefore write a tight downside and a wider upside — for example minus two per cent, plus three per cent — and buyers in promotional retail sometimes write zero on the downside with a make-up obligation instead.
3.3 Price and freight on the excess
Say explicitly that accepted excess is invoiced at the contract unit price — that is what CISG Article 52(2) defaults to anyway, so writing it changes nothing except the argument. Then settle the part the law leaves open: who pays the freight, insurance and duty attributable to the excess. On air freight for a bulky crochet line, the freight on a three per cent overrun can exceed the margin on it. Either the seller absorbs it or the excess is not shipped.
3.4 One settlement route, chosen in advance
| Route | Mechanics | Best when |
|---|---|---|
| Credit note | Shortfall valued at contract price, deducted from the balance | Order is complete and the shortfall is small |
| Make-up in next order | Shortfall carried forward as a quantity credit with an expiry date | Repeat programme with a known next order |
| Make-up before shipment | Factory produces the missing pieces before the balance is released | Shortfall is material or the SKU is launch-critical |
Pick one and name the trigger. "Shortfalls within the band settle by credit note; shortfalls beyond the band are made up before the balance is released" is enforceable. "Shortfalls to be discussed" is not.
3.5 The notice window and the evidence
Fix a window — commonly stated in days from arrival at the destination — and fix what counts as proof: the carton-level count sheet, photographs of the opened carton with the shipping mark visible, and the inspection record. Under Article 621 a silent buyer is treated as having accepted the quantity, so a generous window costs the seller little and protects the buyer a great deal. The reverse also holds: a factory that keeps its own final-inspection tally can answer a claim in a day instead of a week.
4. Three clauses you can paste
The wording below is a starting point, not legal advice — have your own counsel check it against the governing law you nominate.
Buyer-weighted. Quantity tolerance: minus 1% / plus 3% of the ordered quantity per SKU. Shortfall within the band shall be settled by credit note at the contract unit price. Shortfall exceeding 1% shall be made up before the balance is released, or at the buyer's option deducted at 110% of the contract unit price. Excess within the band may be refused in whole or in part; accepted excess is invoiced at the contract unit price with freight and duty borne by the seller. Quantity claims must be notified within 14 days of arrival with carton-level count sheets.
Balanced. Quantity tolerance: plus or minus 3% per SKU, provided the total invoice value does not exceed the order value by more than 3%. Differences within the band settle by credit note or by make-up on the next order, at the buyer's election, at the contract unit price. Excess beyond the band may be refused; the seller bears return freight. Quantity claims must be notified within 10 days of arrival, supported by count sheets and photographs of the opened carton showing the shipping mark.
Seller-weighted. Quantity tolerance: minus 3% / plus 5% per SKU, reflecting irreducible losses at final inspection of hand-crocheted goods. Shortfall within the band settles by credit note at the contract unit price. Excess within the band is shipped and invoiced at the contract unit price, with ocean freight borne by the buyer. Claims outside the band require written notice within 7 days of arrival accompanied by carton-level count sheets.
5. Sets are where shortages hide
A gift set amplifies the problem geometrically. If a three-component set is assembled from batches each running at a two per cent shortfall, the set-level shortfall is not two per cent — components run out at different times, and towards the end of the run the factory is holding a surplus of two components and a deficit of the third. The cartons look full; the sets do not exist.
Two drafting fixes. First, order components to the set quantity plus the band, not to the set quantity, so that a component shortfall does not propagate. Second, require set-level confirmation at packing: a line on the packing list stating sets completed, not pieces packed. That single line converts a discovery at the buyer's warehouse into a number on a document.
6. Over-shipment under a letter of credit
Where a credit is involved, the tolerance clause and the credit must agree. Three workable patterns:
- Build the band into the credit. State the quantity as a range, or state the amount with headroom above the order value, so a three per cent overrun still draws cleanly. Do this at credit issuance — it cannot be fixed at presentation.
- Ship in two lots. A first lot at the round number, a second lot sized to absorb the difference. Where partial shipment is allowed, this removes the discrepancy risk entirely at the cost of one extra set of documents.
- Cap the invoice, credit the rest. Invoice only to the credit amount and settle the physical excess outside the credit. Workable, but it separates goods from payment and needs a written side agreement.
What does not work is assuming Article 30(b) will cover it. On a per-piece toy order it will not, and the discrepancy appears at the counter, not at the factory.
7. How the number gets established
A tolerance clause is only as good as the count it applies to, and the count is where hand-made goods differ most from machine-made ones. Three practical rules:
- Count at the last point where the goods are still ours. Counting after the container is sealed means counting someone else's problem. A tally at the factory gate, per carton, signed, is the only number that can be defended later.
- Count per SKU and per colour, not per order. A run of 5,000 pieces across eight colourways can hit the order total exactly while two colourways are short — and those two are the ones the buyer cannot sell around.
- Keep the rejection record. The final-inspection tally showing pieces pulled and the reason for each is what turns "we think we were short" into a documented shortfall, and it is also the record that justifies a band wider than one per cent in the first place.
8. Our own internal band
For context on how this reads from the manufacturing side: on our own bulk orders we work to a three per cent band per SKU, quoted per colourway, and we state the counting point as the factory gate. Pieces rejected at final inspection are recorded with a reason code, and the tally is sent with the shipping documents whether or not anyone asks for it. Where a shortfall is going to land outside the band, we say so before the balance is called for release rather than at the port — because a factory that reports its own shortfall early keeps the argument commercial, while one that reports it late turns it into a documentary one.
The band itself is not the valuable part. The valuable part is that both sides know, before the yarn is bought, which number will be applied and who pays for the difference. See spec-to-bulk tolerance for the dimensional and weight side of the same problem, and payment terms and deposit structures for how the settlement routes above interact with the balance, and the nine inputs a factory needs before quoting for what to settle before the order is priced.
9. Questions buyers ask about tolerance
Is three per cent the standard tolerance?
No — there is no standard. Three per cent is a common commercial starting point in garment and craft sourcing, and a defensible one, but it binds only because it is written into the order. Without a clause there is no band at all, and every deviation becomes a dispute about breach rather than a calculation.
Does the five per cent rule in UCP 600 apply to a toy order?
Usually not. Article 30(b) allows five per cent either way only where the credit does not state quantity as a number of packing units or individual items. Plush and crochet toys are ordered and packed per piece and per carton, which is precisely the excluded case. Article 30(a) allows ten per cent, but only where the credit itself uses the words about or approximately.
What happens if the factory ships more than ordered and payment is by credit?
The invoice exceeds the credit amount, which is a discrepancy the bank may refuse. The excess then sits at destination unpaid until it is settled separately. The fix is to size the band into the credit at issuance, or to ship in two lots so the second lot can absorb the difference.
Can I simply refuse a short delivery and cancel the order?
Only where the shortfall amounts to a fundamental breach. Under CISG Article 51(1) the remedies for non-conformity apply to the missing part; the whole contract can be avoided only if the shortfall is fundamental. In practice a shortfall inside a few per cent is settled by credit note or make-up, not by cancellation.
How long do I have to claim a quantity shortage?
Whatever the contract says — and if it says nothing, the window is a reasonable time, with a two-year outer limit under Article 621 of the Chinese Civil Code. Silence is treated as acceptance that the quantity conforms, so the notice window is worth negotiating as carefully as the percentage. Fourteen days from arrival, with carton-level count sheets required, is a workable balance.
Who pays freight on the extra pieces?
Whoever the clause says. The law settles the price of accepted excess — contract rate — but says nothing about freight, duty or insurance on it. On a bulky crochet line moving by air, freight on a three per cent overrun can exceed the margin on those pieces, which is why the clause has to allocate it rather than leave it to goodwill.
Does the tolerance apply per order or per colour?
Per colour, always. An order of 5,000 pieces across eight colourways can total exactly right while two colourways are short, and those two are the ones that cannot be sold around. Stating the band per SKU and per colourway is the difference between a clause that protects the buyer and one that protects the total.
Related: yarn count and consumption in crochet costing — how Ne, Nm and tex convert, why a label and a laboratory disagree on the same cone, and the three errors that move a yarn line.
Want the clause pre-filled for your order? Send the SKU list, colourways and the payment method, and we will return a tolerance clause matched to your settlement route — credit note, make-up or pre-shipment completion — with the counting point named.