Home / Journal / Cargo insurance and claims
Cargo Insurance for Crochet Shipments: What a Policy Covers
Cargo insurance is a contract that pays for physical loss of or damage to goods while they are in transit, on the terms of the clauses named in the policy rather than on the terms of the Incoterm; the trade term decides who buys it, and the clause decides what it pays for. Those are two different questions, and conflating them is the single most expensive mistake in this part of a purchase order.
Most buyers of crochet, plush and handmade textile programmes buy insurance the way they buy a courier label: as a line on the invoice, priced at a fraction of a per cent, confirmed by a certificate that nobody reads. It works until something goes wrong, at which point the certificate turns out to be written on a clause that covers the ship hitting a rock and very little else. For soft goods the losses that actually happen are not the ones that clause was designed for.
This note is about the four questions a buyer should be able to answer before the first carton leaves: which clause is the policy written on, where does cover start and stop, which exclusions will be argued at claim time, and what evidence has to exist at the moment of damage. It does not repeat the document pack that travels with the shipment, which is covered in the export documents piece, nor the marking and carton identity system handled in the shipping marks note.
1. Three documents, three different jobs · 2. A, B and C: what each clause actually pays for · 3. Why the default under CIF is close to useless for crochet · 4. Where cover attaches, and the sixty days · 5. The four exclusions that decide crochet claims · 6. Insured value, deductible, and how a partial loss is paid · 7. The claim file · 8. Two clocks, and why one of them is much shorter · 9. What to write in the purchase order · 10. Questions
1. Three documents, three different jobs
Three documents get confused constantly, and each answers a question the others do not.
| Document | Question it answers | What it does not answer |
|---|---|---|
| Incoterm (CIF, CIP, FOB, DDP) | Who arranges and pays for carriage and insurance, and at which point risk passes | What the insurance covers, and how much it pays |
| Insurance policy or certificate | What perils are covered, for what sum, from where to where, and on whose interest | Who is liable for the damage as between buyer and carrier |
| Contract of carriage (bill of lading) | Who carries, under which liability regime, with what limits and liberties | Whether the goods were insured at all |
The consequence of the confusion is visible in thousands of small disputes: a buyer on CIF terms believes the seller has insured the goods, which is true, and believes the insurance will pay for the damage he found on opening the carton, which is often false. The seller has complied with the term by buying the minimum cover the term requires. Compliance and adequacy are different standards.
There is a second layer worth naming, because it decides who can claim at all. Marine insurance is a contract of indemnity against loss of an insurable interest. The Institute Cargo Clauses state it directly at clause 11.1: to recover, the assured must have an insurable interest in the subject matter at the time of the loss. On CIF terms risk passes when the goods are on board at the port of shipment, so the buyer acquires the interest at that moment, which is why the certificate has to be assignable and why the name on it matters. A certificate issued to a trading company that is not the contracting buyer, and never endorsed, is a document that someone will have to explain later.
Finally, the word "policy" is doing a lot of work. What governs the relationship is the clause set named in the policy — typically the Institute Cargo Clauses of 1 January 2009, in the A, B or C form, possibly with additional clauses for war, strikes, or specific risks. Everything below is about those clauses, because that is where the money is decided.
2. A, B and C: what each clause actually pays for
The three Institute Cargo Clauses are not three grades of the same product. They are two different drafting techniques. Clause (A) grants cover for all risks of loss of or damage to the subject matter, and then removes specific things by exclusion — clause 1 says exactly that, subject to the exclusions in clauses 4, 5, 6 and 7. Clauses (B) and (C) work the other way round: they list the perils that are covered, and anything not on the list is not insured, however reasonable the claim may look.
| Clause | Drafting method | Principal perils covered | What it typically misses |
|---|---|---|---|
| (A) | All risks, then exclusions | Everything not excluded: handling damage, crushing, water ingress, theft of the whole or part, contamination, non-delivery of a package | Deliberate acts, ordinary wear and tear, inadequate packing, inherent vice, delay, war and strikes unless bought back |
| (B) | Named perils | Fire and explosion; vessel stranded, grounded, sunk or capsized; overturning or derailment of land conveyance; collision with an external object; discharge at a port of distress; earthquake, volcanic eruption or lightning; washing overboard; water entering the vessel, hold, container or place of storage; total loss of a package overboard or dropped during loading | Theft, pilferage, non-delivery, handling damage, crushing, contamination, rain damage away from the water-entry peril |
| (C) | Named perils, narrower | Fire and explosion; vessel stranded, grounded, sunk or capsized; overturning or derailment of land conveyance; collision with an external object; discharge at a port of distress; general average sacrifice; jettison | Everything in the B list that was added for water and earthquake, plus theft, handling damage, crushing, non-delivery |
Read the (C) column twice. Seven heads of cover, all of them about something catastrophic happening to the carrying vessel or vehicle. There is no head of cover for a carton that arrives crushed because it was at the bottom of a stack, none for a pallet that was dropped by a forklift, none for a container that sweated and left the outer layer of a hundred plush toys with mould spots, and none for the twelve cartons that were never delivered. Those are the four most common crochet losses.
The Incoterms position is the part buyers most often miss. Under Incoterms 2020, the CIF rule requires the seller to obtain cover complying with Institute Cargo Clauses (C) or similar terms, while the CIP rule requires cover complying with Institute Cargo Clauses (A) or similar. The drafting group's reasoning, stated in the ICC's own explanatory material, is that CIP is used for manufactured goods moving by any mode, where the minimum should include more than the vessel-casualty perils appropriate to bulk commodities. In both rules the requirement is a default: the parties remain free to agree a higher level, and a buyer who needs (A) simply has to say so in the contract.
Two further points about the C rules, because they are counter-intuitive. First, the seller paying for insurance does not mean the seller carries the risk. Under CIF, risk passes on board at origin; under CIP, at the point of delivery to the first carrier. The seller's insurance obligation runs to the destination named in the contract, but the buyer is the party whose goods are at risk for most of the voyage, and the buyer is normally the party entitled to claim. Second, a certificate that says "CIF, insurance included" tells you nothing about the clause. Ask for the clause set by name, and read the insured value and the deductible while you are there.
The Chinese clause set, and why the names do not map one to one
When the policy is issued in China rather than on London wording, the clause set is likely to be the ocean marine cargo clauses of a Chinese insurer, whose three basic covers are known as FPA, WA and All Risks — in Chinese, 平安险, 水渍险 and 一切险. They are habitually mapped onto (C), (B) and (A), and the mapping is roughly right in ordering: FPA is the narrowest, All Risks the widest, and All Risks is written on an all-risks-then-exclusions basis. But the mapping is not an equivalence. The Chinese clauses have their own structure, their own exclusions and their own claim conditions, and a dispute will be decided on the wording actually issued, not on the equivalence someone assumed at quotation stage.
The practical rule is short: read the clause set named on the certificate, and if the certificate names no clause set, treat that as a defect and ask for a corrected one. Insurance that cannot be described in a clause reference is insurance that will be argued about later.
3. Why the default under CIF is close to useless for crochet
Consider what actually damages a shipment of crochet animals, crochet flower stems and crochet home textiles, in the order of how often it happens.
- Compression and crush. Cartons are stacked, and soft goods do not resist. A plush toy that has been flattened for three weeks does not recover its shape, and the buyer's customer sees it. This is handling damage, and it is not a (C) peril.
- Moisture and condensation. A container crossing a climate band sweats. Natural fibre absorbs, and the visible result is mould, musty odour or dye migration. Water entering the container is a (B) peril, added in the 2009 wording precisely because it was a gap. It is not a (C) peril.
- Pilferage and short delivery. Handmade goods are small, light and easily pocketed. Theft and non-delivery are (A) perils. They are not (B) or (C) perils at all.
- Handling tears and hook damage. The carton is opened at a customs inspection with a blade, or dragged across a pallet corner. Again (A) only.
- Total loss of the vessel or a container overboard. This is what (C) is for, and it is the least frequent of the five.
So a buyer who accepts the CIF default on a crochet programme has bought cover for the rarest event and none for the four most common ones. The premium difference between (C) and (A) on soft goods is small in absolute terms — a fraction of a per cent of the insured value — which makes the decision easy once it is framed correctly. The framing that works in a purchase order is not "please insure the goods" but "cover to be Institute Cargo Clauses (A) 1/1/2009, including theft, pilferage and non-delivery, insured value 110 per cent of invoice value in the contract currency".
One caution on buying up. Additional clauses are bought for specific perils and are not a substitute for the main clause. War and strikes cover is normally written as separate clauses that reinstate what clause 6 and clause 7 of the (A) form exclude: war, civil war, revolution, rebellion, insurrection, capture and seizure (piracy excepted from the exclusion, so piracy is covered), and loss caused by strikers, riots, civil commotion, terrorism or persons acting from a political motive. On some routes that matters a great deal; on none of them does it fix a packing problem.
4. Where cover attaches, and the sixty days
The duration clause is where claims quietly fail, and it is identical in the A, B and C forms. Clause 8.1 provides that the insurance attaches from the time the insured subject matter is first moved in the warehouse or place of storage named in the contract, for the purpose of immediate loading, continues during the ordinary course of transit, and then terminates on whichever of four events happens first:
| Termination event | Clause | What it means in practice |
|---|---|---|
| Completion of unloading at the final warehouse at the destination named in the policy | 8.1.1 | The normal, intended ending |
| Completion of unloading at any other warehouse the assured elects to use for storage outside the ordinary course of transit, or for allocation or distribution | 8.1.2 | Routing goods through your own distribution centre ends cover there, not at the final customer |
| The assured elects to use a vehicle or container for storage outside the ordinary course of transit | 8.1.3 | A container parked in a yard for six weeks is storage, not transit |
| Expiry of sixty days after completion of discharge from the ocean vessel at the final port of discharge | 8.1.4 | The clock that catches inland legs, customs delays and port congestion |
Clause 8.3 keeps the insurance in force during delay beyond the assured's control, deviation, forced discharge, reshipment, transhipment and any variation of the adventure arising from a liberty granted to the carrier. That is broader protection than most buyers expect, and it means a transhipment that sits for three weeks at a hub does not by itself end cover. What it does not do is extend the sixty days in 8.1.4, which runs from discharge at the final port regardless of why the goods are still sitting there.
Clause 9 covers the harder case: the carrier terminates the contract of carriage at a port other than the destination named. Cover then also terminates unless prompt notice is given and continuation is requested, in which case it may be held, subject to an additional premium, until the goods are sold and delivered, or for sixty days after arrival, whichever is first. This is the clause that decides whether a shipment abandoned at a hub is insured while it waits for a decision, and it requires the assured to act — "prompt notice" is an obligation, not a formality.
For a crochet programme the practical consequences are three. If the destination is a port and the buyer's warehouse is four hundred kilometres inland, the inland leg is inside cover for sixty days from discharge, which is usually enough and occasionally is not. If the buyer's goods go into a consolidation centre for allocation to retail stores, cover ends at that centre under 8.1.2, and the onward legs need their own arrangement. If the port is congested and the container waits five weeks for a slot to be railed, the sixty days are being consumed by the wait.
5. The four exclusions that decide crochet claims
All three clause forms share the general exclusions in clause 4, and four of them are the ones argued about on soft goods.
4.3 — packing: the exclusion that turns on who packed
Clause 4.3 excludes loss, damage or expense caused by insufficiency or unsuitability of packing or preparation of the subject matter to withstand the ordinary incidents of the insured transit, where such packing or preparation is carried out by the assured or their employees or prior to the attachment of this insurance. The clause defines packing as including stowage in a container, and defines employees so as to exclude independent contractors.
That parenthesis is the whole argument. If the supplier packed the cartons before the insurance attached — which on a CIF shipment is the normal sequence, since cover attaches when the goods are first moved for loading — then the exclusion is available to the insurer, and the question becomes whether the packing was sufficient for the ordinary incidents of the transit. If a third-party logistics provider packed at the buyer's instruction after attachment, the position is different.
For crochet and plush goods the packing questions that get asked are specific. Was the carton board strong enough for the stack height in the container, or was it a five-layer board chosen for cost and crushed at the bottom of a nine-high stack? Was there a moisture barrier, and was it a sealed poly bag or a loose liner? Was desiccant used, and was it calculated against the volume and the transit time, or was one sachet dropped in per carton? Were the goods compressed to save volume, and if so, what was done to protect the shape? A buyer who wants to win a packing argument later should specify packing in the purchase order and retain the specification, because the specification is the evidence that the packing was suitable for the transit the parties contemplated.
4.4 — inherent vice
Clause 4.4 excludes loss, damage or expense caused by inherent vice or nature of the subject matter. For natural fibre this is the exclusion that meets the moisture claim: if the yarn went into the carton above the equilibrium moisture content for the destination climate, and the mould that follows is the goods spoiling from the inside, the insurer will point at 4.4 rather than at the container. The counter-evidence is a moisture content record at packing, a sealed barrier and desiccant calculation, and photographs of the container interior showing condensation on surfaces rather than only on the goods. Dye migration between colours in a humid container is argued the same way.
4.2 — ordinary loss and wear
Clause 4.2 excludes ordinary leakage, ordinary loss in weight or volume, and ordinary wear and tear. Handmade goods are not usually sold by weight, so this exclusion rarely bites on quantity; it does bite on the argument that a certain proportion of handmade pieces always arrives with a minor defect. If the acceptance standard in the purchase order allows a percentage of minor defects, that percentage is not an insured loss — it is the contract working as agreed. The AQL regime in the pre-shipment inspection note is where that line belongs.
4.5 — delay
Clause 4.5 excludes loss, damage or expense caused by delay, even where the delay is caused by an insured peril, except expenses payable under clause 2 (general average and salvage). The commercial consequence is that the late-season shipment which misses the retail window is not an insured loss, however painful. Cover pays for the goods, not for the missed season.
Two more exclusions are worth knowing even though they are not crochet-specific: 4.1, wilful misconduct of the assured, and 4.6, insolvency or financial default of the vessel's owners, managers, charterers or operators where the assured knew or should have known at loading that it could prevent the normal prosecution of the voyage. The proviso to 4.6 protects a buyer who has taken the policy by assignment in good faith, which is another reason the assignment chain matters.
6. Insured value, deductible, and how a partial loss is paid
Cargo insurance is an indemnity, and the indemnity is capped by the sum insured. Under Incoterms 2020 the CIF and CIP rules require cover of 110 per cent of the contract value in the contract currency, and the extra ten per cent exists to cover the buyer's expected profit and the incidental costs of a lost shipment — the freight paid, the financing cost, the cost of replacing the order at short notice. A certificate written at 100 per cent of invoice value is compliant with nothing in particular and leaves the buyer's margin uninsured.
Three numbers decide what a claim actually pays.
| Number | Where it comes from | How it goes wrong |
|---|---|---|
| Insured value | Invoice value plus the agreed percentage, in the contract currency | Quoted in a different currency from the invoice, so the conversion is disputed at claim time |
| Sum insured | The cap stated on the policy | Set below insured value on a rising order, creating average — the insurer pays the loss in the proportion the sum insured bears to the insured value |
| Deductible or franchise | Negotiated, stated in the policy | A deductible per claim wipes out small losses; a franchise means losses below the figure are not payable at all but losses above it are paid in full |
Partial loss is where the arithmetic becomes visible. If a consignment of a thousand crochet animals is insured for 11,000 dollars and two hundred are destroyed, the claim is not two hundred times the unit price; it is the insured value multiplied by the proportion of the consignment lost or damaged, less the deductible, subject to the salvage. Where the goods are damaged rather than destroyed, the measure is normally the depreciation in value at destination, which is why a survey that records the damage before anything is moved matters more than a photograph taken a week later.
The salvage point is worth stating plainly: goods that are damaged but still worth something have a value, and the insurer is entitled to it, or to have it credited against the claim. A buyer who sells the damaged stock and then claims the full loss will be asked about the proceeds. The clean sequence is to notify, survey, agree the treatment, and only then dispose.
7. The claim file
The claim is a documentary exercise, and the document list is not a suggestion. The Chinese ocean marine cargo clauses state it as an obligation: on claiming, the assured must provide the original policy, the bill of lading, the invoice, the packing list, the weight note, the certificate of damage or shortage, the survey report and the claim schedule; and where a third party is liable, the correspondence pursuing that party and any other necessary documents. The clauses go on to provide that where the assured fails in this documentary duty and the insurer cannot verify the loss, the insurer is not liable for the part it cannot verify. A parallel obligation sits earlier in the same clauses: on discovering a loss the assured must apply immediately for survey to the agent named on the policy, and on finding a whole package short or visibly damaged must obtain a damage or shortage certificate from the carrier, the bailee or the relevant authority, and give written notice of claim to the responsible party, obtaining an extension of time where necessary.
Translated into a sequence that works at a destination warehouse:
- Stop, before unpacking. Photograph the container or vehicle, the doors, the seal number, the carton stack and the damaged cartons in place. A photograph of a damaged toy on a table proves the toy is damaged and nothing about when.
- Record the handover documents. The equipment interchange receipt, the seal number on the bill of lading against the seal on the door, the tally and any remarks the receiving clerk wrote on the delivery note. A clean receipt signed without remarks is the single most effective way to lose a claim.
- Notify in writing, to the right parties. The insurer or its named agent, and the carrier, separately. A reservation of rights to the carrier is not the same letter as a notice of claim to the insurer, and both are needed.
- Request a joint survey before the goods move. Insurer's surveyor, carrier's representative where they will attend, and the buyer's own representative. Where the carrier will not attend, record that they were invited and did not.
- Preserve the packing. The carton, the poly bag, the desiccant sachet, the pallet wrap. Packing is the physical evidence for exclusion 4.3 and it is routinely thrown away in the first hour.
- Quantify and keep the arithmetic visible. The claim schedule should show the insured value, the proportion lost or damaged, the deductible, the salvage credited, and the resulting figure. A claim submitted as a round number invites a round-number counter-offer.
One sentence on who does this. On CIF and CIP terms the buyer is normally the party with the insurable interest during the ocean leg and the party at the destination who can survey. The supplier's role is to have the documents ready — the packing specification, the moisture record, the loading photographs, the seal number — and to answer quickly when the insurer's surveyor asks how the cartons were packed. In our own practice the packing specification and the loading photographs travel with the shipping documents for exactly this reason: they cost nothing to produce at the time and cannot be reconstructed afterwards.
8. Two clocks, and why one of them is much shorter
Two limitation periods run at the same time after a marine cargo loss, and the shorter one belongs to the party the insurer will eventually want to sue.
| Claim | Period | Runs from | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Against the insurer under the marine insurance contract | Two years | The occurrence of the insured event | Maritime Code of the People's Republic of China, Article 264 |
| Against the carrier for cargo loss or damage | One year | Delivery or the date on which the goods should have been delivered | Maritime Code, Article 257 |
| Recourse by a party held liable against a third party | Ninety days | Settlement of the original claim, or receipt of the court documents | Maritime Code, Article 257 |
The structure explains a behaviour that otherwise looks puzzling. The insurer pays under a two-year clock and then steps into the assured's shoes against the carrier under a one-year clock which, by the time of payment, may already have run. Article 252 provides that where the loss was caused by a third party, the assured's right of claim against that party transfers to the insurer on payment, and the assured must provide the necessary documents and assist the insurer in pursuing the third party. Article 253 then provides that where the assured has, without the insurer's consent, given up the right of claim against the third party, or by fault caused the insurer to lose the right of recourse, the insurer may reduce the indemnity accordingly.
The practical instruction that follows is blunt: never sign away the right to claim against the carrier in order to get the container released, and never let the one-year period pass while arguing with the insurer. Written notice to the carrier, an extension of time where the carrier will grant one, and a copy of both to the insurer, is the sequence that preserves everyone's position.
Where the policy is on London wording rather than Chinese, the governing law and jurisdiction clause at the end of the clause set decides which limitation regime applies, and English law and practice is the default in the unamended form. That is a reason to read the last clause of the policy as carefully as the first: the clause set that pays for the loss and the law that decides the dispute are printed in the same document, and buyers routinely know the first and not the second.
9. What to write in the purchase order
Eight lines, in the insurance article of the purchase order, cost nothing and remove most of the argument.
- The clause set by name and date: Institute Cargo Clauses (A) 1/1/2009, or the named Chinese clause set, not "insurance included".
- Extensions bought deliberately: theft, pilferage and non-delivery; war; strikes; and the specific risk the route justifies.
- Insured value: 110 per cent of invoice value in the contract currency, with the currency named.
- Deductible: the figure, and whether it applies per claim or per shipment.
- Transit scope: named place of origin, named final destination, and whether the inland leg and any distribution centre are inside the cover.
- Who is the assured, and the assignment mechanism if the certificate is to pass to a bank or a buyer.
- Packing specification, referenced and attached, including carton board grade, stack height, moisture barrier and desiccant basis.
- The claim documents the supplier must retain and hand over, and how quickly: loading photographs, seal number, moisture record, packing specification.
None of this requires a specialist. It requires somebody on the buying side to notice that the insurance line on a purchase order is the only line where the price is measured in tenths of a per cent and the exposure is measured in the whole order.
Is cargo insurance the same as the carrier's liability?
No, and the two are often confused in exactly the situation where the difference costs money. The carrier's liability is limited by the applicable convention or national law and is typically expressed in units of account per kilogram, which for light handmade goods is a very small number relative to the value of the carton. Cargo insurance is a separate contract that pays the insured value, subject to its exclusions, and it then pursues the carrier by subrogation for whatever the carrier's limit allows. A buyer with insurance and no carrier claim recovers from the insurer; a buyer with a carrier claim and no insurance recovers the convention limit and nothing more.
My supplier says CIF includes insurance. Is that enough?
It is enough to comply with the CIF rule, which requires cover complying with Institute Cargo Clauses (C) or similar. It is not enough to protect a crochet shipment, because the (C) cover list is limited to vessel and vehicle casualties and excludes theft, handling damage, crushing and non-delivery. The fix is one sentence in the contract: cover to be Institute Cargo Clauses (A) 1/1/2009. The premium difference on soft goods is a fraction of a per cent of the insured value.
Are FPA, WA and All Risks the same as (C), (B) and (A)?
In ordering, roughly; in substance, no. The Chinese clauses known as 平安险, 水渍险 and 一切险 map onto (C), (B) and (A) closely enough that people speak of them as equivalents, and All Risks, like (A), is written as all risks subject to exclusions. But each set has its own exclusions, its own duration wording and its own claim conditions, and a dispute is decided on the wording on the certificate. The safe practice is to name the clause set and the date, and to read the exclusions page before the first shipment rather than after the first loss.
If the cartons are crushed, is that covered?
Under (A), yes, subject to clause 4.3 on packing — the insurer will ask whether the cartons were sufficient for the ordinary incidents of the transit, and who packed them. Under (C), no: crushing is not among the listed perils. Under (B) it is also excluded, since the B list covers water entry and earthquake rather than handling damage. This single example explains why the choice of clause matters more for soft goods than for almost any other cargo.
Cover ends when?
On the first of four events in clause 8.1: unloading completed at the final warehouse named in the policy, unloading completed at any other warehouse the assured elects to use for storage or distribution, the assured electing to use a container or vehicle for storage outside the ordinary course of transit, or sixty days after completion of discharge from the ocean vessel at the final port. Transhipment and delay beyond the assured's control do not end cover under clause 8.3, but they do not extend the sixty days either.
Who has to prove the packing was adequate?
In practice the assured does, because the exclusion is written as an exclusion and the insurer only has to raise it. The evidence that answers it is a packing specification agreed before production, the carton board grade, the stack height the specification was designed for, the moisture barrier and the desiccant calculation, and loading photographs. Without those documents the argument becomes an assertion against an assertion, and the insurer's assertion is the one written into the policy.
Can we claim for a shipment that arrived late and missed the season?
No. Clause 4.5 excludes loss, damage or expense caused by delay, even where the delay was caused by an insured peril, with the exception of general average and salvage expenses under clause 2. Late delivery is a performance question under the sale contract, which is why the delivery clause and the tolerance for delay belong in the order, not in the insurance discussion.
How long do we have to claim?
Two years from the occurrence of the insured event against the insurer under Article 264 of the Chinese Maritime Code, and one year from delivery against the carrier under Article 257. The second is the dangerous one, because the insurer will want to pursue the carrier after paying, and Article 253 allows a reduction in the indemnity where the assured has given up the right of claim against the third party or let it lapse. Written notice to the carrier at the time of damage, and a copy to the insurer, preserves the position for both.
Related: HS classification for crochet goods — the four headings that compete, the chapter notes that separate them, and why a cushion, a bouquet and a raffia tote do not share a code.
Buying crochet on CIF and not sure what the cover actually is? Send us the clause reference and the insured value from your certificate, and we will tell you which of the four common crochet losses it pays for — and what the packing evidence would need to look like if a claim were made.